Independent regulatory information. No operator promotion, no commissions. Published under the editorial policy.
Home/Explainers/Courts
✓ Facts on this page last verified September 22, 2026

Skill, chance and the courts: India's gambling case law

The Supreme Court cases that separated skill from chance, the state laws struck down for crossing the line, and where the 2025 Act leaves it.

For nearly seventy years Indian gambling law turned on one question: is the game one of skill or one of chance? The answer decided whether a state could prohibit it. This page traces the decisions. Case texts are linked to Indian Kanoon, the public case-law archive; the Supreme Court’s own record is the authoritative source.

The three Supreme Court decisions

State of Bombay v R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala (1957). The Court held that gambling is not trade or business protected by Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, but competitions involving a substantial degree of skill are. States may regulate and prohibit gambling; they cannot treat a skill competition as gambling.

State of Andhra Pradesh v K. Satyanarayana (1968). Rummy was held to be a game preponderantly of skill, so playing it for stakes in a club was not gambling under the state statute. The test that emerged: a game is one of skill if skill predominates over chance.

Dr K.R. Lakshmanan v State of Tamil Nadu (12 January 1996). Horse racing is a game of skill, and betting on it is not gambling within the Tamil Nadu statute. On-course betting through licensed turf clubs rests on this decision.

The online cases

When states tried to prohibit online games of skill, the courts applied the same test.

All India Gaming Federation v State of Karnataka (High Court of Karnataka, 14 February 2022). The Karnataka Police (Amendment) Act 2021, which criminalised online games played for stakes including games of skill, was struck down as beyond the state’s competence and contrary to Article 19(1)(g).

Similar challenges were brought against the Tamil Nadu Act of 2022 and the Kerala notification of 2021, with results that this site will record once the official judgments are on the record it relies on.

Where the 2025 Act leaves the distinction

The Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act 2025 prohibits online money games whether of skill or of chance. It does so under Parliament’s powers rather than a state’s, so the competence argument that defeated Karnataka’s law does not apply in the same form. Whether the Act’s blanket approach survives an Article 19(1)(g) challenge is a question the courts have been asked. This site records decisions, not predictions, and will add each judgment to the timeline as it is published.

Sources

Case texts: Indian Kanoon. Supreme Court judgments: Supreme Court of India.